Box-Killa's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[{B.A.B.} Final Resistance WIP]

nice

I love it and i can feel the emotion in the song, especially at the beginning.

What I love mostly is that you found your style of music, that you love and enjoy to make. I am still in the process of finding what I like most. At the moment i've been dabbling in dance but I think I would enjoy making songs, sort of like paragonx9, but of course in my own way. I enjoy to listen to your songs, although it is very hard to fully grasp all the accents and emotion of a classical instrument, made electronically, you are certainly doing a good job of it. Keep up the good work :D

blackattackbitch responds:

I guess I kinda did find my preferred genre of music, although, to be honest, this was always the direction I was headed in, since summer of '08.

Man, thanks for reminding me, I never got around to checking your songs out. It's been months now, sorry.

Glad you noticed my efforts to really emulate real instruments, it's extremely difficult to say the least.

About finding your voice, just wait. It'll come naturally. Have you ever made a song where you just kept composing for hours on end, never getting bored, and when you finally finish, you sit and listen to it repeatedly? That's when you know you've found your voice.

Thanks for the review, man!

[Hidden Deep Within - Piano]

awesome

I dont think it sounds that mechanical, it really is awesome. In no way does it deserve a 9. I agree that it is so much tougher to make piano, bass, drums, saxaphone, sound real when make elec music, but this was done well concidereing. Unless you record you wont get the perfection...

this was very professional though. I love the tune, Who really cares about mechanicalizmm anyway if it creates a good atmosphere.

Could do with a better climax though, I thought that was a let down

If you are not busy can you take a look at this? (take out the spaces)
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/274547

shadow6nothing9 responds:

Actually I changed around the tempo and velocities right after Rwin's review. So it did help, sorta. He's a bad man and needs to be nuedered xD He better give me a 5 now :p

One says I'm simple, u say pro. Just Tell me how it makes u feel sheesh. :p

Big big thank u! For reviewing.

[Spank [Cartref]]

Interesting, needs mastering

The tune is pretty cool but unfortunately My score was stumped at an 8 because the quality is very poor.

this is very interesting and fun to listen to but you should make it sound really nice, mastering. When taht screaming thing happened i though there was someone behind me lol 1:10,

Nice sounds, You should make a propper song now, with a melody and such, it think you have great talent but you need to structure it and then learn how to master your sounds so they sound perfect

If you are not busy can you take a look at this? (take out the spaces)
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/274547

Cartref responds:

Hey dude, cheers for the review it was really helpful, got any tips on how to sort out sound quality?
Yeah I need to practice a lot more its just finding the time.
Will check that link out now dude.

[Jetpack paladin's Flight]

interesting

It sounds very 8-bitish, with that cool sterio effect on 1 thing. I like it, very creative and shows how you can make an epic song in less than 1 minute.

You need to work on adding some cool 8-bit drums and then you will have yourself a 10.

Other than that the sound is perfect! Good job keep it up.

Oh and take a look at this song I made, I think you will enjoy it

(PutThisfterthedotcom)/audio/listen/2 74547

Calamaistr responds:

sure ill listen to your song mate, thanks for the review. It strikes me as a suprise some people have been voting extremely low though, if this isnt game music then what is?

Ohwell, cant please everyone, or perhaps they were very young not aware that once upon a time now called retro there existed game music that was far superior in composition than most of any music around today. ;)

Oh btw, i didnt think actual drums would go with it so i used bit - snares instead 'as drums ;)
I wanted to keep the music 100% 16b style see. (not 8b no that would be with only one or two sounds to work with hehe :P )

regards- Calamaistr.

[SN |Pristine| SN]

OOHHHNOTANOTHERONEEAHHHHHH

Lol well at least you found your style, my style is everything lol. It is pretty cool. I would like some structure, very experimental in structure. Very professionally sounding, mastering is awesome. I suppose if anything this was good mastering practice. You've got some wierd and wonderfull effects in there. It is a nice song, interesting to listen to. For me it isn't that easy to listen to, but it is interesting, cool and I can see the effort. Good to see you are improving. Now make a techno song, at least lol! Peaceout!

SessileNomad responds:

i love my style xD

lol i dont really make genreic techno tracks anymore, but mabye just for you... :)

peace out dude

SessileNomad

[Twista Shifta - Lust]

nice jazz

Could do with some mastering. A lot of mastering. I like the experdimental side of things. Good job on that behalf. Now that synth hert my ears near the beggining.

Check this jazz song i made. http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/273443 (take out spaces)

Chris-86 responds:

Thanks, ya, I admit, I didn't go back and tweak very much on this one. And I already heard that song. It's not really jazz, it's more blues in my opinion.

[Britishnessism]

interesting

it is a very flat sound. Try adding some reverb. Nice voice lol. I like the bass, although a bit heavy. now check out this song http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/273443 (take out spaces)

Chris-86 responds:

By te way, know it's not a ery good sound. Trustme, I didn't spend too much time on it, it was supposed to be a mildly funny song.

[Ice (Ringtone) - F-777]

Aweshum

Nice lead :D Now you have to inform the person after you...

F-777 responds:

Thanks man =). Made it with 3xosc.
Glad you like it!

Ye i pm'ed triplestar.

Your part is awesome btw.

[Experiment 2: Dream Alter]

great

I love the experimentalism. Also I was wearing headphones. Lol dun worry about the first 100 votes or so. When ure score is 2 and you have 200 votes, then you should be worried. Long song, would be nice to be compressed in time, and less repeditive.

Trypno responds:

Thanks for listening, as well as the input on votes.
I think one day I might go back in and do a few things with this, perhaps shorting it and making a jam, but I'm currently liking where it's at. Thanks for the input :)

[Flash/Audio Collab Submission]

Its nice

I like. Nice mastering. Im sick of hearing glitch from u lol. Make some jazz! It's a challenge.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/269718

Lol to this song and then another song popped up with the same timing and it sounded cool.

SessileNomad responds:

lol

get used to it, glitch is the shit

jazz is really hard to make, theres a reason i dont make it xD